Sunday, 19 August 2012

Critical Analysis


How / what is the meaning of your work?

My work is an advertisement for a car. This medium requires eye-catching colours, premise and ideas.  The idea behind it was also to let the advertisement potentially become a viral campaign, and in order to create a successful viral advertisement, it is important to allow the main product to seem secondary while actually being of primary importance to the piece, which I did by not showing until the end that the oak tree is growing from the car itself.

How / what is it supposed to communicate to an audience?

The target audience for the piece is young people in their twenties buying their first car. In this day and age, environmental concerns are very important, and this particular car – the Seat Mii – is an environmentally friendly car, so I showed this in a visually striking way by associating it closely with nature and showing a tree growing from its exhaust pipe.

I asked several people about this idea before exploring it, and I have seen first-hand the impact a car with flora growing from it has on a community, as I have been to Kensington market on multiple occasions, where there is a car decorated by residents that has many plants growing from it.

Why are particular techniques employed and how do they impact on the piece?

I used digital cut-out animation in the piece. I believe this helps with the idea of partnering mechanics and nature, which is what I was doing with the car and the tree.


Your chosen style, form and content

I used bright colours to make the image more striking, and to associate the product with positive feelings. I also gave the tree natural textures to support the idea that the car is at peace with nature.


Your shot construction

I used a close up of the acorn at first so that the first thing we see is an element of nature, then the camera follows the squirrel up the tree, and only pans out at the end to reveal that the tree and car are one. I did not want to reveal the tree growing from the exhaust until the end of the advertisement, and until that point I wanted the focus to be on the squirrel.


Your chosen format

The piece is thirty second long, as I wanted to keep it short and to the point, since this is how advertisements should be. A long advertisement will likely bore the target audience and not sell the product.

In what way has critical work assisted your practice?
What research methods have you adopted and how have they informed your work?

I researched by finding successful viral advertisements and asking other people to recall advertisements that had gone viral in the past which stuck in their minds. I reviewed these advertisements and came to the conclusion that the product needed to appear secondary to the piece at first, which I did not do in my original project work when I opened the advertisement with an image of the car. I believe this advertisement works much better as a potential viral video than the other has.


What experimentation have you conducted and why?

I went through ideas of how the car and the tree could be shown together, whether it should be on top of it or growing from within the car, or growing out of the exhaust as it is in the final piece.

I also initially considered just showing the camera following the path of a tree and ending up at the car, but I decided it would be better to give the audience a character of sorts to watch instead, to keep their attention, and then reveal at the end that he was not the main focus of the advertisement as a whole.

From what traditions of film-making /fine art / popular culture has your work emerged?

I researched into other advertisements to see what approaches were successful. I have also looked at music videos aimed at the same age group as my target audience, and my style of animation was based partly on this research.


Does your film challenge any easily held notions that are in existence?

It combines nature and a car, which is not an idea that is explored too often.

Does your pre-production successfully communicate your idea?

I believe my pre-production communicated my idea well. I was blogging regularly throughout the process, and I think the development of my idea is rather clear.

Who is the audience for your work?

The audience for the piece is drivers in the twenties.

What issues does this raise?

Due to concerns about global warming and our carbon footprints, advertising a car to educated young people can be difficult, but since the Mii is environmentally friendly, it is important to stress this fact so that the audience can see the benefit to buying this car over any other.

It is also important to keep the message of the piece short, clear, and striking, so as to capture and keep their attention long enough to let them see what is important.

How has your process been influenced by your awareness of your audience?

I think my audience are quite aware of the environment and the damages of carbon emission, and so would be looking for cars that leave a smaller carbon footprint. As such, it was important for me to realise that this is the most important feature of the Mii, and focus on this trait within the advertisement.

What social, political issues may have informed your work?

The work is mainly informed by the issue of global warming and how much humans have contributed to this problem.


How successfully has your work achieved its meaning?
How might your work be mis-read?

I believe that the concept is simple enough that it should not be misread. The car is displayed in a very bright and positive manner, and it is clear that the tree is flourishing as opposed to being destroyed be the car’s emissions.

What issues regarding distribution and exhibition may effect your work?

I do not own the rights to the music I have used in my piece, however if they need to be obtained I could do so with relative ease as I have talked to the people who wrote and performed the song before and we are certainly on positive terms with each other.

How has your practice moved on?

In comparison to my original attempt at the Media 2 project, I believe my practice has moved on a considerable amount. I researched into viral advertising in a much more effective way and came to concrete conclusions about the medium before I began to develop my idea. I think I learned more from advertising this time around and incorporated it into my piece in a much better manner.



No comments:

Post a Comment